The other day I had a customer asking if there was a difference in transfer speeds between external enclosures using the eSATA or USB interfaces. I told them that eSATA is, of course, the fastest interface for external enclosures and that if there was a speed difference from enclosure to enclosure it would be negligible at best. But I'm not entirely convinced that that is the case, I then bought one of our generic Chronos USB and eSATA enclosures (great price after staff discount

) and threw a 250GB Seagate hard drive in it.
My plan is to get everyone to do a few quick transfer tests on their external enclosures USB, eSATA or both, to see if there is any real difference between dives (ie. no name brand like mine vs others).
Thanks in advance for any contributions!
Here are my results:
1.8GB of Pictures Transferred Back and Forth to the Root dir on each drive.
Each Test is run 3 times.
eSATA
Upload: 26.9s, 26.9s, 28.1s
Download: 26.5s, 26.9s, 26.3s
Up Avg: 27.3s
Down Avg: 26.56s
USB
Up: 70.8s, 69.6s, 70.2s
Down: 59.6s, 58.2s, 59.2s.
Up Avg: 70.2s
Down Avg: 59s
HD Tune Results: