Hardware Canucks

Hardware Canucks (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/)
-   Storage (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/storage/)
-   -   Seagate 2TB - ST32000641AS vs. ST2000DM001 (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/storage/55587-seagate-2tb-st32000641as-vs-st2000dm001.html)

Ajiki-kun July 19, 2012 04:25 PM

Seagate 2TB - ST32000641AS vs. ST2000DM001
Both are 2TB, 7200RPM drives, and disregarding price for the moment, what is the difference between the two? I've heard a lot about the noise the ST2000DM001 makes when it parks its heads.

JD July 19, 2012 06:09 PM

Barracude XT is their "RAID Edition". In theory, better RAID support, longer MTBF and 3yr warranty.

My brother just got the ST1000DM001 and it's been perfectly fine. No audible noise from it and it's a pretty quick drive since it has 1TB platters. This is the 1TB model though.


Ajiki-kun July 20, 2012 09:34 AM

Thanks for the reply.

I've decided to go with the Barracuda XT.

Truth is, I actually bought a ST2000DM001 2 and a half months ago, and I've been wrestling with Seagate support for the past 2 months trying to get rid of that chirping noise, then trying to update firmware to no avail, and finally getting multiple bum replacements.

It looks like the first iteration of the 1TB/platter / Advanced Format+7200RPM has been a bumpy transition, at least for Seagate. They agreed to swap it for a new XT instead, which I think is a pretty good deal, and I should be able to ride out the 3 year warranty until they work out the kinks and I need to upgrade.

AkG July 20, 2012 11:28 AM

All seagates chirp. Just all WDs make a more "click" sound. Nature of the platter and spindle beast. IF the chirp is LOUD then I would look to your PSU. Seagates are more sensitive to voltage ripple than some....BUT they let you KNOW when they are not happy.

Yank the drive and try on a different rig with a different PSU. It is possible that you got bad luck...but I would bet its a PSU issue and not a pure HDD issue....that or you are just more sensitive to their chirp (ie your ears are sensitive to that range of Hz the noise resides in). If so....sound deadening material for your case (or better case) is a wonderful investment. ;)

Ajiki-kun July 21, 2012 08:46 AM

Thanks for that bit of knowledge. I never knew other Seagates also had that problem.

That said, I've had multiple PSUs to test on (purely coincidental; I was testing for VGA coil whine at the time), and back then, I always thought the sound was just coming from my PSU fan winding down. Turns out the chirping was coming from the new drive. (Btw, I own another older Seagate 1tb drive. Now that you mention it, it also has the "chirp" but it was never noticeable until I took a very careful listen while doing some tests yesterday)

From what I've read from user reports, even if the chirping is normal, the frequency at which it happens for the ST2000DM001, and other 1TB/platter drives, is not, on the lines of every 2 minutes. It seems like the only way to fix that is to disable APM via third-party software like CrystalDisk.

Anywho, I'm hoping, maybe baselessly, that the older replacement drive will have less or no chirping, or at least have it less pronounced like my 1tb.

NyteOwl July 21, 2012 10:09 AM

XT are not Seagate's RAID optimized drives. Those are the ES drives (WD's are RE series) and you pay a healthy premium for them over conventional drives.

enaberif July 21, 2012 01:58 PM

I thought xt was the laptop line?

AkG July 21, 2012 02:01 PM

It is in the Momentus 2.5" notebook line. The 'cuda XTs are the older gen 3.5" 7200rpm high performance drives. Seagate dropped the "XT" off the end for the NEW 1TB platter std hdd 'cuda as in all likelihood they will be bringing out a 3.5" Hybrid...which will get the "XT" moniker. OR atleast that is the plan / rumour that I heard last. No idea if it will ever come about, but if they DO buy OCZ its almost a given. ;)

Ajiki-kun July 25, 2012 01:13 PM

Just as an update:

The XT rocks! It works just as quietly and painlessly as my 1TB drive (ST31000524AS), no chirping or high load count. This is what I should have gone for to begin with!

EDIT: The Barracuda XT has a very similar looking model name as my older 1TB Barracuda (ST31000524AS vs ST32000641AS) and all the drives that are reported to chirp are the new ST1000, ST2000 and ST3000, etc.

All times are GMT -7. The time now is 08:04 PM.