Hardware Canucks

Hardware Canucks (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/)
-   Storage (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/storage/)
-   -   Replace HDD? (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/storage/28770-replace-hdd.html)

Hunt February 10, 2010 11:42 AM

Replace HDD?
 
So, I have a couple questions that Google hasn't been very kind in answering.

I was thinking of replacing my HDD, which is a Seagate 7200.10 500GB since it's on the noisy side. It may be my imagination, but it seems to be getting noisier, so I've got a hunch that it may bite the dust in the future.

Is it possible to install a 2nd HDD, say a 7200.12 or Caviar Black (open to suggestions), mirror the primary drive, then swap the drives so the new HDD becomes the primary? I'd probably keep using the old one just as storage for unimportant stuff. Or am I better off doing a full system wipe and starting from scratch?

Also, would there be any noticeable difference in speed from an 7200.10 to one of the drives I mentioned?

MarkOne February 10, 2010 11:51 AM

Yes , I recommend you install a fresh windows. it will give you also the opportunity to make a good cleaning, you will appreciate the gain in performance too ...... unless you want to keep a special software that you can't reinstall ( i see quite a few of them, in my work , specialise one, with the programmer out of business )

Canker February 10, 2010 11:56 AM

Yes, you can clone your hard drive onto a new one.

Seagate provides free software you can download to do this with their drives (DiscWizard).

Western Digital also provides free software to download (Acronis TrueImage) which accomplishes the same thing, and is probably better than Seagate's DiscWizard.

If you replace your hard drive with one which is a year or two newer, it's almost a given the replacement will be faster than the model it replaces, whether you will notice that difference is questionable.

I like Seagate hard drives and had long sworn off Western Digital because of problems I had with their older models, but for the past few years I've found them to be solid.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Hunt (Post 331752)
So, I have a couple questions that Google hasn't been very kind in answering.

I was thinking of replacing my HDD, which is a Seagate 7200.10 500GB since it's on the noisy side. It may be my imagination, but it seems to be getting noisier, so I've got a hunch that it may bite the dust in the future.

Is it possible to install a 2nd HDD, say a 7200.12 or Caviar Black (open to suggestions), mirror the primary drive, then swap the drives so the new HDD becomes the primary? I'd probably keep using the old one just as storage for unimportant stuff. Or am I better off doing a full system wipe and starting from scratch?

Also, would there be any noticeable difference in speed from an 7200.10 to one of the drives I mentioned?


Hunt February 10, 2010 12:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MarkOne (Post 331762)
Yes , I recommend you install a fresh windows. it will give you also the opportunity to make a good cleaning, you will appreciate the gain in performance too ...... unless you want to keep a special software that you can't reinstall ( i see quite a few of them, in my word , specialise one, with the programmer out of business )

Software isn't an issue, just don't want to spend the 3-4 hours setting everything up again. I just recently put on Win7, and don't want to go through it again so soon.

It's mainly because I'm lazy. Maybe I'll just do the full upgrade (mobo, cpu, ram, and HDD) all at once and do a fresh install again. Hopefully my HDD lasts for another little while.

Canker, thanks for the info regarding the software! Greatly appreciated.

MarkOne February 10, 2010 12:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hunt (Post 331785)
Software isn't an issue, just don't want to spend the 3-4 hours setting everything up again. I just recently put on Win7, and don't want to go through it again so soon.

+1 very annoying.

Don't know if cloning work well under 7 , never try it , just make sure you select the good drive, we don't want you copy the new disk in the old one.

But think about my improvement in speed if you make a fresh install. Even if you put a new drive, it will not improve if your OS is a mess, and they are always messy after a wild :thumb:

gingerbee February 10, 2010 01:31 PM

there's always Ninite Easy PC Setup - Download/Install Multiple Programs Fast it always help save time. jmo

Raserei408 February 10, 2010 01:35 PM

For HDDs:

If you're planning to get under 1TB I recommend the Caviar Black 640GB. If you're looking at 1TBs I'd take the Spinpoint F3 (though the Caviar Black is a good option too, but it's more expensive and slower. Still, better warranty and apparently RMA service in Canada).

I'd check out a program called HDClone. It's OS-independent; you burn it to a disk, boot from the CD, then it copies over the HDD outside the OS. The free version, I believe, can only go to a HDD the same size or larger than the original, which shouldn't be a problem in this case. Not sure how this compares to Seagate's and WD's programs.

Hunt February 10, 2010 01:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gingerbee (Post 331817)
there's always Ninite Easy PC Setup - Download/Install Multiple Programs Fast it always help save time. jmo

Awesome suggestion! Wish I had of known about that program earlier. Thank you!

SugarJ February 10, 2010 02:25 PM

I've used DriveXML from the Ultimate Boot CD (ubcd4win.com) to successfully clone drives multiple times.

And I love ninite.com, I just used it last week, painless unattended install of a bunch of essential programs for any new Windows install.

odis172 February 10, 2010 02:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Raserei408 (Post 331819)
For HDDs:

If you're planning to get under 1TB I recommend the Caviar Black 640GB. If you're looking at 1TBs I'd take the Spinpoint F3 (though the Caviar Black is a good option too, but it's more expensive and slower. Still, better warranty and apparently RMA service in Canada).

.

+1 Samsung spinpoint F3 1tb, just ordered 4. Havent used samsung hard drives before but ive read good things about them. F3 comes in 500gb and 1tb flavor (500gb platters)


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 05:52 AM.