HMMMM Suspicious?!?!

[Cptn Vortex]

So.....3dGamerman, everyone knows him some way or another. The video reviews....

Watch through that....tell me if there is somehting you recognize.... say, this image? From our own review here???

Palit Radeon HD4870 512MB Graphics Card Review

Look about 2:47 into the video clip! Looks to me like SKMTL's image EXACTLY, only with the water mark removed!! Someone lazy enough not to want to void their warranty for review purposes methinks!!!

[death_hawk]

Normally this wouldn't be really suspicious, but what draws my suspicion is the fact that everything else has a "live" GPU, whereas the removed shot is an image. THAT makes me suspicious.

[Cptn Vortex]

Then Check These!!

[Cheator]

Check the power cord for the Fan. Its not there in the video.

[Cptn Vortex]

Yah, I see that. may have been removed

[Mibs]

Well the power cord could easily be edited out...I'm not sure if 3DGameMan would go that far to try and hide what he did...

[Cptn Vortex]

Looks like a rip off to me....... I noticed the terms and conditions here, Hardware Canucks - Computer Hardware Reviews, News and Benchmarks - contact

" Please note that the images posted on Hardwarecanucks.com which are watermarked with the Hardwarecanucks logo may not be copied or replicated without the written approval from the Hardwarecanucks staff. To receive approval please write to skymtl@hardwarecanucks.com."

Wonder what will happen when the guys upstairs see this....

[MacJunky]

Make a video that exposes him and post it on youtube? Nothing too harsh, just politely exposing and asking that he please contact you for permission first next time?
After all, if we piss him off we loose an opportunity to potentially have the HWC and SKYMTL names mentioned on youtube. If gone about correctly we might be able to get those names where more will see them and well, you know what that equals. :P

Though on the other hand ripping others off just so you don't void your warranty is really low and he may not be deserving of using images like that even if he asked.

[SKYMTL]

The site in question was contacted. They have denied it is ours even though I can tell you that it is either a damn good copy (which it really doesn't seem to be) or indeed ours. The fan angle is the same, the little dent I put in the ram's thermal pad is there, my lame reapplication of the VRM thermal pad is shown, the shadows are the same and when superimposed the images line up to a tee.

At this time we are still deciding what route to take since this usage is in clear violation of our Terms and Conditions. No, we were not contacted with a request to use it...a request we have granted many times in the past I may add. In addition, all diplomatic routes between the two sites was stopped at the behest of the owner of the site in question after we offered to allow them to use it as long as the watermark was reapplied.

I must say I am disappointed since I count myself as a diplomatic type of person and I wanted a quick resolution to this.

[MpG]

At the very least, doesn't YouTube pay lip service to not hosting copyrighted material without permission? Might be able to get the video pulled from there that way.

[Supergrover]

Slime.


That is all I have to say.

[Cptn Vortex]

I hope you get some form of explanation or apology. At this level of professionalism, plagiarism is just uncalled for.

[Cptn Vortex]

Looks like we got the ball rolling too. Plausible Deniability? 3dGameman Rips off Hardware Canucks Copyrighted Images? - XtremeSystems Forums

[SKYMTL]

At the very least, doesn't YouTube pay lip service to not hosting copyrighted material without permission? Might be able to get the video pulled from there that way

Personally I don't want it to come to that if possible.

[Dashock]

lol were gettin so big people are stealing our stuff lol! yea lookin at the images closely its ours! Definetely hope Skymtl gets an apology! Keep up the great work man!