Go Back   Hardware Canucks > HARDWARE > Power Supplies

    
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #11 (permalink)  
Old November 25, 2007, 01:45 PM
Rookie
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Saskatchewan
Posts: 14
Default

Good job as usual - loved the shredded Smurf comment :D

I have to nitpick on the Nmedia and Mushkin though just a bit. Huntkey/SCY is known to rate their units at peak values which ends up being 100W more than they're good for, so the Nmedia really is a 400W unit. The ripple results tend to back this up.

The Mushkin on the other hand... let's just say I wasn't impressed when jonnyGURU reviewed it and I'm not impressed now. 12V combined at 28A and a high 3.3V/5V combined indicates a very old design to me - 12V is too low for a good recent design 550W unit and is likely prone to some crossloading issues when really loaded since it's a group regulated design. It's also missing parts of the transient filter on the PCB. To be fair, so is the Nmedia, but that one is a whole lot cheaper by contrast. As usual, rail fusion does nothing at all... it's likely just a single 12V design with some current sensing parts to turn on that LED.

Good job on the rest... it's a good read. I'd probably put the lot of them in this order: Silverstone, FSP, Coolermaster, Enermax (also a really old design), Mushkin, Nmedia.
Reply With Quote
  #12 (permalink)  
Old November 25, 2007, 01:51 PM
Digitaldemon's Avatar
MVP
F@H
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: 2 miles south of heaven.. east of eden
Posts: 308
Default

500 watts appears to the bare min now... the max being in my estimate 850..

In my personal experience.. I had 2 cm extreme power psu's , 1 was rated at 600 and the other was at 650...

The 600 worked fine with my old p4 set up... the 650 worked fine with a low end pcie card and machine... [total working computer's=4].

they did not work fine with 1 8800gtx card and a new processor, and 2 more hd's these were the 1st things i changed as time went along... out went the x1950 ati pcie and E2180.. I assumed that the 600 would be fine.. but when the machine failed to load.. I figured .. i would try the 650 instead.

The machine did not still power up...

I proceeded to take it to a friend, the 650 psu, he has the same evga 8800gtx 2gbs of ram deal with 4 500gb hd's but a ocz 750 watt psu. We encountered the same problem.. ... he reinstalled his power supply and it was fine.

To see if it was my psu I reinstalled it onto my old p4.. and it loaded.. the cooler master psu could not handle the power requirements of the higher ends stuff.

I know some friends who swear by silverstone and blue storm, these people are not enthusiast's, just average people with some knowledge to upgrade and do work on a pc, but not oc or anything nice. But again the store I shop at didn't not carry em, neither did the other 2 stores. So could not try them.

My point is coolermaster psu's are mediocre in performance and I would not recommend them to anyone, sad at one time I would of ... To be honest I even tried the m700 version.. and returned it... and decided to go with ocz.. So off I went again to gather a 750.. store was out, so took ocz's 700 watt psu, very stable.. not the 750 but nice and quite, it is stable so far.
__________________


Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Comment Thread for Ultra 400W & 500W Review SKYMTL Power Supplies 9 April 9, 2009 06:02 PM
Comment thread for MM U2-UFO worklog Babrbarossa Water Cooling 38 June 3, 2007 03:24 AM
Comment Thread for 2GB Flash Drive Roundup SKYMTL Storage 4 May 16, 2007 06:17 PM
A teaser of the 500W PSU Roundup!! SKYMTL Reviews & Articles from the Web 9 March 14, 2007 06:37 AM