Hardware Canucks

Hardware Canucks (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/)
-   Networking (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/networking/)
-   -   KillerNic (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/networking/26-killernic.html)

Gav November 6, 2006 06:39 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Not really software, but this seemed like the most appropriate area.

What's everone's thoughts on this product, hype or not?

Attachment 15


UNESCO November 6, 2006 08:13 PM

Hype. Not competing with a router that's less than half it's price (and it's a whole freakin' router!) plus only delivering on a few games... pass.

The most promsing aspect and probably the most expensive to implement is FNapps and the thing is broken. Oh, plus their horrible driver support and penchant to erase drive images after an install really screams confidence. Oh well, I'm sure there'll be thousands sold to Quad-SLI 8800GTX owners to go along with their Ageia PhysX cards and Creative Fata1ity X-Fi soundcard. Oh wait... the KillerNIC is on the PCI bus, there's no room on the motherboard for all those; silly me! :rolleyes:

Misoprostol November 6, 2006 09:21 PM

Personally I'd choose this over a physX card....

But I only have one PCI slot open, so sound card it is :)

These companies are shooting themselves in the FOOT. Here's how a meeting of a board of directors goes:

Ignorant Executive 1: "Let's launch a product aimed at the enthusiast with more money than brains

Ignorant Executive 2: "Great idea Cletus, but everything from CPUs to video cards has already been covered.... Why we even have high end 'gaming' sound cards"

Ignorant Executive 1: "Oh sh*t. Well what the hell can we possibly market to people with too much money?"

Ignorant Executive 2: "How about hard drives... WITH WINDOWS"

Ignorant Executive 1: "Everyone has windows on their hard drive. Why do you think they call it a monopoly"

Ignorant Executive 2: Not THAT kind of Windows (TM ). I mean like plexiglass windows!

Ignorant Executive 1: ......That's already been done. Western Digital went down that path.

Ignorant Executive 2: Wait.... here it is.... A NETWORK CARD!

Ignorant Executive 1: "Why, that's ingenious! Why bother eliminating the internet as a bottleneck? It's more less expensive for us to manufacture large pieces of metal on network cards than a genuinely useful piece of hardware"

Ignorant Executive 2: "You're right on. Nevermind that wireless is the future... Remember that even though this is just a network card, we have lots of high end planning to do. What sort of network card should it be?"

Ignorant Executive 1: "Well I heard of this PCI Express thing, but I'm pretty sure that the express part is optional"

Ignorant Executive 2: "You're right. Our target market is gamers with high end systems and money to blow. They have *lots* of PCI slots that won't be filled with important things like sound cards and TV tuners"

Ignorant Executive 1: "Let's get this baby to market. It's gonna be KILLER"

Ignorant Executive 2: "You're onto something! No one will want to buy a NIC when they could have a KILLER NIC"

Ignorant Executive 1: Gentlemen (note right now that there are only actually two executives present including the speaker. This should accurately reflect the intelligence of Exec1) we have our product.

r00tman March 29, 2007 09:03 AM

LOL!!! :thumb:

catguy April 2, 2007 06:58 PM

now ain't that a joke
250 bucks for a NIC card, hey, i like the ONE USB port :rofl:

sswilson June 18, 2007 06:23 PM

Yet another review on this one......

techPowerUp! Review :: Bigfoot Networks Killer NIC M1 :: Page 1 / 9

They're making some pretty hefty claims.

One of the things I didn't realise (didn't pay that much attention to it) was the fact that it incorporates a mini-pc and that the USB port can be connected to an external drive to allow stand-alone torrent use.

Still an awful lot of money, but if it can actually deliver FPS, in FPS games maybe there is a market for it.

Supergrover June 18, 2007 07:21 PM

I have looked @ these a few times if it work it would be sweet in 2142, but for the price forget it.

sswilson June 18, 2007 07:30 PM

Well, if folks are willing to spend real world money for uber items to equip their on-line personas, I can see them being willing to put up the cash for an extra 10-20 FPS.

This of course is if it actually works.

There must be some form of on-line benchmark which could give us something other than subjective "i went into the same areas and tried to do the same things" readings.

The theory behind seems to be sound, I'm just not convinced yet that real world apps would show much benefit.

kcksteve September 22, 2007 08:35 AM

i realy like this product and i would buy one since i do mostly online gaming only if the price was lower, hopefully the price will drop in the future and ill pick one up

BALISTX September 22, 2007 09:52 AM

It helps in a few games, but it's not worth the cost. The card is not going to increase the speed of your Internet connection, if anything it will increase the speed going from your PC to your modem, but on average your connection from a 100 Mbps NIC to the cable/DSL modem is between 1ms to 5ms you will not notice a difference when you are doing online gaming. The only way you will notice a difference is if you run benchmarks. IMO this card is a complete waste of money and is worthless crap

All times are GMT -7. The time now is 12:48 PM.