Hardware Canucks

Hardware Canucks (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/)
-   Member Reviews (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/member-reviews/)
-   -   'No Russian' - An emotional response - MW2 Review (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/member-reviews/27299-no-russian-emotional-response-mw2-review.html)

mattlef January 2, 2010 11:32 AM

'No Russian' - An emotional response - MW2 Review
 
Did they push a tad too far?

A review of ‘No Russian’ in Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

http://playstationlifestyle.net/wp-c...are-2-logo.jpg


Disclaimer:

The following contains spoilers. Please do not read if you plan on playing the game in the near future.
This was also written as a review on a mission, and the emotional response of the writer right after completion.

And no, IW has not paid me anything for this.
Everyone is entitled to their opinion, and as such, please respect those who wish to voice theirs
I didn't write this to start a flame war. I wrote this to spur educated and civil discussion.






-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
With its newest release of the Call of Duty series, Infinity Ward has stirred emotional response from gamers worldwide. The response varies depending on the platform used to play. Console gamers rejoice at how the game is challenging and exciting, where PC gamers lament the fact that they can no longer have control of their online experience. However, since its launch, Modern Warfare 2 is on pace to out sell any game in the history of Console and PC gaming.

For the sake of those who have yet to dwell deep into the game, I won’t talk about the plot lines. One would rather stir the emotions of those who have yet to experience this game first hand rather than confirm a well known fact to those who already know. This game has pushed the boundaries of what would be deemed acceptable in any shape or form. The first modern warfare did away with the usual battlefield and took the war to the streets. This installment brings the war to your very own backyard, and even closer…

When first beginning the game, the player is asked if they would be offended by a certain mission, deemed ‘No Russian.’ We are informed that completion of said mission would have no bearing on one’s ability to complete the game, but would however further define the plot lines. Of course, due to curiosity alone, one is tempted to say they will not be offended or disturbed.

The following is what happened, and to most that have a sense of decency, even in virtual reality, it shakes you to your core, as it’s all too familiar and all too real. Modern Warfare 2, in an attempt to make the plot lines more deep and in an effort to involve you on a more emotional level, developed this level to shake even the coldest of hearts.

The scene cuts to black. A zipper can be heard and soft spoken Russian fades into the background….
The black dissolves to an elevator filled with men. Heavily Armed men….. The Character and his compatriots step out of the elevator to the concourse of a Russian airport. Lines of travelers, young and old, male and female, prepare for their journey ahead of them.

Your character takes a breath, and all together they open fire into the group.

At this moment, as a player, I don't even know how to process whats going on. Mowing down everyone in sight. Women and children, dragging their bloodied love ones to only have their virtual lives cut short by your own virtual hand. You are, for a moment a terrorist. Together the group moves slowly, taking aim at civilians as well as security. Each body that moves is taken down, and those who by some miracle are alive, have their lives finished as the group moves deeper into the airport. Bodies and blood cover the floor... I feel sick to my stomach, and it’s all over as quickly as it began. I take a deep breath and attempt to quality what has just transpired. My blood is boiling, my head spinning. Half expecting C.S.I.S. to rope in at any moment, to throw you in plastic cuffs and haul you off, I step away to reflect. The realism of such a mission has taken me by surprise. I'm not an emotional person either. Part of me wished i didn't select the 'I won't be offended' option. The other part is even more into the game, because of how real it felt. Yet, I'm more reflecting on everything that has gone on in the past few years. Reflecting on the state of the world and how a game can do this to me. I just committed an act of terrorism, all be it in a game.... Nothing feels right, It left me to wonder, Was this too soon? Was this mission even needed?



Am I being over sensitive in assuming that this is not even remotely acceptable in any shape or form? It’s one thing to have a scene in a movie where lives are taken in a terrorist act, or in a Tom Clancy book, but it’s entirely another to have it happen in front of you, and you’re the unwilling trigger man. It’s not real. You know it’s not real, yet somehow it still affects you as if it was. You feel the same renewed hate and anger you felt on that one autumn morning in 2001. That same stricken feeling you once had during the Munich Olympics. How can a virtual world evoke such emotions? How can something such as this affect you as deeply as it is now? With the ‘mission’ over, your character gone…. We are just left to reflect on what could possibly be the most controversial mission ever implemented in a video game ever.
A game that promised to deliver an experience that was second to none. A realistic view on the global political conditions, and what could potentially happen if it all went wrong…

Do i personally believe that this game pushed the envelope? Yes, a resounding and concrete Yes. Do I believe that this was needed to make the game better? No. Does this mission develop the plot line? Yes however a simple cut scene would have sufficed. However in saying that this mission does add to the game in regards to the development of the plot as well as elicit an emotional response from the gamer, should have IW attempted to deliver the same response in a different way? Could have it been more tactfully executed? Do you think the warning was sufficient considering?



So, I pass this on to those who have, and have not played this game….
What is your opinion? How do you feel about this being implemented in the game? How did you feel when playing it?


Thund3rball January 2, 2010 12:05 PM

Is it tasteless, imo yes. But so is GTA as far as I'm concerned. I haven't played this and I generally don't play GTA games. The Warning is only going to make people even more inclined to go through the mission, whether they want to or not. Curiosity will prevail.

I did play a bit of a couple other missions from this on my nephews 360 at Xmas. I thought the gameplay was pretty fun and the action well done. This whole controversial mission is in the game for PR and sales. And I'd have to say it's working.

gingerbee January 2, 2010 12:29 PM

Video game movie I don't think there's a difference at all well movies are allowed to be more graphic. and yes i think the point of the stage was just story line but clearly the story works fine with out it so was the point to push things a lot I would say so.

But oddly i didn't think much about it until i saw this thread I just played the game through and thought that was a level a bunch of people are going to get mad about it. jmo but this is 1 of those game kids should not play but they will and do play it all the time. ( I don't have children so I can't really say anything on that )

controversy sell games :thumb:

Kayen January 2, 2010 12:46 PM

Kids love shooting hte crap out of innocent people.

BT! January 2, 2010 12:49 PM

big friggin deal.. movies show way more gore and disgusting shit.
theres a warning at the start that you can choose not to play those levels.. the game is rated Mature 17+.

b1lk1 January 2, 2010 12:52 PM

This will spread like wildfire and help sell millions more copies and people that weren't gonna buy it will just to see this. Bold marketing move if you ask me.

Dar_ell January 2, 2010 01:01 PM

I seen worse stuff, i wonder why MW2 is getting so much attention compared to other games.

Kayen January 2, 2010 01:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dar_ell (Post 311097)
I seen worse stuff, i wonder why MW2 is getting so much attention compared to other games.

Due to it's insane popularity at the moment .

AkG January 2, 2010 01:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dar_ell (Post 311097)
I seen worse stuff, i wonder why MW2 is getting so much attention compared to other games.

Maybe because IW is doing everything they can to screw over PC gamers?
Like the old saying goes "all publicity, be it positive or negative, is GOOD publicity".
I cant comment on the no Russian level as I refuse to give a dime more to those SOBs till they change their ways so I havent played it.

miggs78 January 2, 2010 01:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AkG (Post 311112)
Maybe because IW is doing everything they can to screw over PC gamers?
Like the old saying goes "all publicity, be it positive or negative, is GOOD publicity".
I cant comment on the no Russian level as I refuse to give a dime more to those SOBs till they change their ways so I havent played it.

Ditto.. I could even download the demo, but I refuse to play that game.. PC Gamer Rule.!!


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 07:37 PM.