Well after getting tired of my WDHD live box I started reading about the new atom/ion boxes that were perfectly matched for HD playback via XBMC. If you havent already heard XBMC is X-Box Media Centre, one hell of a HTPC front end in my eyes.
After doing some research and reading up on systems and prices, I fell on the Zotac mag, cheaper then the Acer, no OS which I was not going to need, black and shiny and sleeker looking in my eyes. I think I paid around $230 for mine, that and a 1tb 2.5" external and a $25 IR remote and I was good to go.
I haven't read much on the net about using the MAGs for this application, theres lots on the Acers but nothing on the mag. So far Ive gotten this setup to work about 90%. Im still struggling with wireless networking, which I dont really plan to use much but wouldnt mind conquering, I havent touched emulators yet either.
I can attest to the fact that setup is fairly pain free for the most part, I used a minimal Ubuntu install along with the XBMC XCI installer.
SourceForge.net: Project xci
Very easy to use, went pretty much without a hitch, once you run it and do the install you have to exit xbmc and do some hardware setup through the installer. I am able to get a wireless signal, but it constantly disconnects when doing even small transfers, and the range is horrible. After doing the IR remote setup from the XCI menu, the remote works perfectly, all the buttons. I managed to get suspend and wake to work through the power button on the remote with a little tom foolery...
Ubuntu Suspend / Wake - XBMC
Helped alot with that.
After testing multiple skins (aeon stark, showmix, auriga and alaska) I settled on alaska, out of all the listed it felt the fastest in menus with the atoms specs. It also looks awesome, and its a touch more customizable then aeon.
Hitchers Alaska development thread...
Alaska development thread - XBMC Community Forum YouTube - Alaska (XBMC) Panel View type
A little youtube clip
Specs of the system im running are..
Atom 330 CPU (dual core)
Nvidia ION GPU (The part that allows for offloading of HD video decoding from the CPU)
2 gb ram
160gb HD
This system seems to handle HD plays well so far, although most of what I will be playing on this system is 720p and under untill I decide to buy a blu-ray drive and start doing my own encodes. A 1080p copy of transformers show now slowdowns, no out of sync audio, no jitters throughout the movie, as is the same with a copy of Ironman.
Now one issue brought up with this system is heat and noise, it does get a touch loud, although mines mounted to the back of my tv, and unless nothing is playing on my tv while the unit is running (very rare for me) then it is inaudible. When the system is not in use, a simple press of the power button puts it into suspend mode, using very little power, dispersing no heat or noise, and a quick press of the power button has the system up and running in a matter of under 10 seconds.
Next task when I get time will be to set up wireless controllers and some emulators and games, untill now the family is really enjoying the ability to watch through my movie and TV series collection without me having to burn 1000 dvds.
Another side note, if you don't know much about xbmc, one HUGE benefit is the scrapers it uses. Basically if you have your movie library setup correctly (proper file names and folder setup) then XBMC will scrape your movies and automatically download the movie information (plots, actors, dates, ect), box art, HD fan art, and if you use a skin like alaska it will also download the media flags, showing what quality the picture and sound are, movie ratings ect. All of these are displayed in your movie library while your browsing it...
YouTube - Alaska (XBMC) Trailer test
Shown here, various view modes for viewing your movie collection as well as trailer support and info.
Ive started this thread to share what ive learned in the process of getting my own mini HTPC setup going, if anyone has any questions ill try my best to answer them or direct you to somewhere that might have them.