Over the past few months we have been testing what seems like an endless number of Z170 motherboards from a wide range of manufactures and a quite a few price points. However, in all those reviews we keep coming back to a few very specific models to use as the benchmarks upon which all others are judged. For budget minded consumers there are two models which stand head and shoulders above the rest thus far: the ASUS Maximus VIII Gene, and the ASUS Z170-A. Neither are perfect, but with their combination of arguably the most polished BIOS and software package available, a good list of features, and good (for their price range) power delivery systems these two models are hard to beat.
While both are very good at what they do and with asking prices of $210 and $160 there is however a rather wide gulf between them. More importantly, the $170-$180 price range is the most hotly contested niche this generation, and neither the less expensive Z170-A nor the over $200 RoG Maximus VIII Gene are necessarily optimal fits for this specific bracket. This is because the buyers who make up this corner of the marketplace may indeed be very budget conscious but they don’t necessarily want the least expensive board they can find. Rather, they don’t mind spending a few extra dollars if it will net them a noticeably “better” motherboard with some extra features.
Recently we took a long hard look at the MSI Gaming M5 and the Gigabyte Z170 Gaming 5 and found them both to be reasonable options for this class of consumer.
Not one to rest on their laurels, or let a noticeably large group of sales go to the competition, ASUS has finally fired back with their answer to the Gaming 5 twins: the Z170-Pro. Coming in at around $180, this model carefully threads the needle between the more expensive RoG Gene, and the rather frugally priced Z170-A.
In order to do this ASUS has started with the inexpensive Z170-A motherboard design and built <i>up</i> instead of using the RoG Gene (or Hero) and cutting down to this price point. With just a quick glance at the specifications consumers could be forgiven for mistaking the Pro for the -A model, as the refinements and improvements are subtle.
To reinforce this “A Plus” impression ASUS has even kept the rather aesthetically pleasing black and white design that caught our eye the first time we saw the Z170-A. However, make no mistake this, the Z170-Pro is the more feature rich model and promises to be the more overclocking friendly board. For a mere twenty dollars’ extra consumers can expect to find an additional PCIe x1 slot (four to the Z170-A’s three), a vastly superior on-board sound solution (ALC1150 based instead of ALC892), an upgraded USB 3.1 controller (Intel-based instead of ASMedia), and best of all vastly superior DDR4 support (DDR4-3866 vs DDR4-3400).
Mix in the same three year warranty, robust all digital 8+2 phase CPU power design of the Z170-A, a high-speed x4 M.2 slot and SATA Express port, USB 3.1 abilities, CrossFire and SLI, a high-quality Intel i219v NIC, as well as the same award winning BIOS and software package and on paper a mere twenty-dollar additional investment looks awfully damn tempting. However, the main competition of the ASUS Z170-Pro are the MSI Gaming M5 and the Gigabyte Gaming 5. As such throughout this review we will be constantly judging its merits based upon these two models – and not just the Z170-A.
<div align="center"><img src="http://images.hardwarecanucks.com/image/akg/Motherboard/Z170-PRO/mfg.jpg" border="0" alt="" /></div>
While both are very good at what they do and with asking prices of $210 and $160 there is however a rather wide gulf between them. More importantly, the $170-$180 price range is the most hotly contested niche this generation, and neither the less expensive Z170-A nor the over $200 RoG Maximus VIII Gene are necessarily optimal fits for this specific bracket. This is because the buyers who make up this corner of the marketplace may indeed be very budget conscious but they don’t necessarily want the least expensive board they can find. Rather, they don’t mind spending a few extra dollars if it will net them a noticeably “better” motherboard with some extra features.
Recently we took a long hard look at the MSI Gaming M5 and the Gigabyte Z170 Gaming 5 and found them both to be reasonable options for this class of consumer.
Not one to rest on their laurels, or let a noticeably large group of sales go to the competition, ASUS has finally fired back with their answer to the Gaming 5 twins: the Z170-Pro. Coming in at around $180, this model carefully threads the needle between the more expensive RoG Gene, and the rather frugally priced Z170-A.
In order to do this ASUS has started with the inexpensive Z170-A motherboard design and built <i>up</i> instead of using the RoG Gene (or Hero) and cutting down to this price point. With just a quick glance at the specifications consumers could be forgiven for mistaking the Pro for the -A model, as the refinements and improvements are subtle.
To reinforce this “A Plus” impression ASUS has even kept the rather aesthetically pleasing black and white design that caught our eye the first time we saw the Z170-A. However, make no mistake this, the Z170-Pro is the more feature rich model and promises to be the more overclocking friendly board. For a mere twenty dollars’ extra consumers can expect to find an additional PCIe x1 slot (four to the Z170-A’s three), a vastly superior on-board sound solution (ALC1150 based instead of ALC892), an upgraded USB 3.1 controller (Intel-based instead of ASMedia), and best of all vastly superior DDR4 support (DDR4-3866 vs DDR4-3400).
Mix in the same three year warranty, robust all digital 8+2 phase CPU power design of the Z170-A, a high-speed x4 M.2 slot and SATA Express port, USB 3.1 abilities, CrossFire and SLI, a high-quality Intel i219v NIC, as well as the same award winning BIOS and software package and on paper a mere twenty-dollar additional investment looks awfully damn tempting. However, the main competition of the ASUS Z170-Pro are the MSI Gaming M5 and the Gigabyte Gaming 5. As such throughout this review we will be constantly judging its merits based upon these two models – and not just the Z170-A.
<div align="center"><img src="http://images.hardwarecanucks.com/image/akg/Motherboard/Z170-PRO/mfg.jpg" border="0" alt="" /></div>
Last edited: