Quantcast
 


HD 6870 & HD 6850 vs. GTX 460 1GB: An Overclocking Study

Author: Michael "SKYMTL" Hoenig
Date: October 28, 2010
Product Name: Radeon HD 6850 / HD 6870 / Geforce GTX 460
Share |

Conclusions


Note, all overclocked cards in the charts below are based upon the highest attained overclock before voltage increase.


GTX 460 1GB


With the release of the HD 6800 series, many predicted hard times for NVIDIA’s GF104-based solutions but through steep price cuts and a large stable of pre-overclocked cards, board partners seem well placed to take on AMD’s onslaught.

What makes things interesting is the GTX 460’s overclocking capability allowing partners to release unique products that pack a ton if improvements over the reference designs. This is where the EVGA GTX 460 FTW can be written into the equation since it provides a performance increase over the reference card that is simply astounding. Even when a HD 6870 is overclocked to 1GHz, the battle between it and the FTW flip flops from one card to the other depending on the game – there simply is no clear-cut winner until you get to ultra high resolutions. With a price of just $229 USD (and even less when you factor in the $10 - $15 mail in rebates being offered) this EVGA card is well within the financial reach of many gamers. This also makes it simply untouchable from a price / performance viewpoint.

These high clock speeds do act like a double edged sword though. While a reference GTX 460 may overclock like no one’s business, the EVGA FTW has very little headroom for further increasing performance. This particular GTX 460 should also be considered a “best case scenario” since it is the highest clocked GTX 460 currently available in the North American market.

With all of this being said, we think GTX 460 1GB cards –be they overclocked or not- seem to have found a perfect niche between the HD 6850 and HD 6870’s price points. Just be aware these NVIDIA products were never meant for ultra high resolution gaming; that’s the realm of the newly reduced $260 GTX 470 and even more expensive GTX 480.


HD 6870 1GB

Our respect for what AMD accomplished with their Barts XT has been well documented but overclocking the HD 6870’s core will lead to a wall in relatively short order. On the other hand, the memory overclocks extremely well.

Without increasing the voltage, our HD 6870 cards all stopped shy of a 10% core clock increase which resulted in a good performance gain when it was paired with the overclocked GDDR5. Upping the voltage by a reasonable amount led us over the 1Ghz mark but any additional upwards adjustments led to rapidly increasing heat, power consumption and noise with next to no additional gameplay benefits.

The overall capabilities of an overclocked HD 6870 really are impressive but this is one card which is literally begging for a custom heatsink. We’ll likely revisit HD 6870 overclocking once AMD’s board partners start tweaking its design; that should really allow this card to shine.


HD 6850 1GB


Considering the HD 6850 uses a slightly cut down version of the Barts core, we were expecting great things and it didn’t disappoint. Even without a voltage bump, it was nearly able to match the HD 6870’s reference clock speeds. Additional tweaking led to clock speeds above the 1Ghz mark but the memory speeds stopped well short of the HD 6870’s achievements.

Performance-wise, our overclocked HD 6850 was able to hang with the HD 6870 in the vast majority of benchmarks but due to its lower shader count, there was sometimes a noticeable gap between the two cards. Upping clock speeds by applying additional voltage brought the HD 6850 in line with its more expensive brother but like all cards, this quickly leads to high heat and diminishing returns in overall framerate increases. Even XFX’s custom heatsink struggled to keep temperatures within check when the core was running in excess of 1Ghz.


Final Thoughts

Buying a new graphics card is usually considered a significant financial investment for many and overclocking is an excellent way to get additional value out of a purchase. Naturally, some architectures have the ability to significantly increase their performance while others are near their limit from day one.

If you are in the market for a sub-$250 graphics card and are comfortable with overclocking while being mindful of the pitfalls, then both the GTX 460 1GB and the HD 6850 should be considered front-runners. They both have some impressive headroom to spare and feature extremely competitive price points. The HD 6870 on the other hand is a purebred racehorse but has tightly constrained overclocking limits at its reference voltage.

For the time being, certain pre-overclocked GTX 460 1GB cards can give NVIDIA’s board partners a slight to significant edge over the HD 6870. You can also buy these NVIDIA cards right now while AMD's board partners aren't quite ready to release products sporting the clock speeds we saw in this article. However, AMD’s AIBs will soon have their own take on pre-overclocking so the market is surely in for some great competition between the $150 and $250 price points in the coming months.



 
 
 

Latest Reviews in Featured Reviews
August 15, 2013
Corsair's Carbide AIR 540 is a unique case.  It uses a distinctive dual chamber design which not only saves vertical space, improves airflow and houses large E-ATX motherboards....
August 11, 2013
Galaxy's GTX 770 GC 4GB doubles up on the reference card's memory while also utilizing higher clock speeds.  It also happens to be one of the most expensive GTX 770 cards on the market but does the ad...
August 5, 2013
Gigabyte's new Z87X-UD5H may be targeted towards the upper end of the mid-range market but it incorporates features normally found on flagship models.  But with such cutthroad competition among Haswel...