Categories




Review Contents:
CPU Water Block Round Up APOGEE GT/GTX vs. STORM vs. FuZion vs. APOGEE vanilla
by Misoprostol     |     April 25, 2007

Complications:

Normally I wouldn’t include a section describing all of the things that went wrong during my testing, but there were quite a few complications involved in the testing of the APOGEE GT/GTX. This block is finicky to mount. Some of my original attempts to mount this block had the APOGEE GT/GTX being beaten by the FuZion by several degrees, while others had them on par or edging out the FuZion by as much as a degree. That’s a HUGE variation.

I contacted Gabe from Swiftech about my mounting problems, and he was kind enough to take some time out of his busy schedule to help me get more consistent mounting with the APOGEE GT/GTX.

First Step: If using a quad core, ensure that the orientation of the inlet and the outlet is perpendicular to the mounting arm (on the 680i. I’m not sure about other boards). Once I reoriented the block, I saw a couple degree difference in load temperatures across all cores

Second Step: Gabe suggested that I try using either a backplate or a motherboard that has not had a different mounting mechanism other than the Swiftech mounting mechanism because he feels that other vendors’ mounting mechanisms may be causing motherboards to flex, which would in theory recess the CPU socket, and cause poor contact with Swiftech mounting hardware. I didn’t play around with this theory too much, but I did switch to a brand new board, and I used a backplate (Thermaltake with ¼” neoprene fom to protect the back of the board) for the rest of my testing. My results improved again marginally once I used a backplate

Third Step: This one I came up with on my own, but I found that by tweaking the amoung of pressure that the 4 screws holding the block together, I was able to get a more centered contact area with the bowed base. For example, if I lifted the block off the CPU to see that the best contact was a little off to the right, then I would loosen the screws on that side a LITTLE bit to try to center it. This worked for me, and enabled me to reduce the difference in temperatures between cores 0/1 and cores 2/3 from 10C to about 4C.

Even after all of these steps, I found the APOGEE GT/GTX, during my official trials were less consistent than the other blocks in this round up and you will see that reflected in their results. Some mounts were better than that, some were worse, but I would rather report what the average user can expect than best case scenario, or worst.
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!Bookmark to Slashdot!Stumble this Post!Reddit! Bookmark to Newsvine!
 

Latest Reviews in Water Cooling
September 8, 2008
In the past we have reviewed several products from CoolIT Systems. Both the Pure and the Elite passed through our lab and both received accolades while never offeri...
June 4, 2008
Even though CoolIT can be considered one of the new kids on the block when it comes to CPU cooling solutions, there isn't a doubt that they have made a name for them...
May 5, 2008
CoolIT hasn't been around for long but in a short amount of time they have proven themselves to be the company to go to for TEC cooling solutions. Today, we test th...
LinkBacks (?)
LinkBack to this Thread: http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/hardware-canucks-reviews/1033-cpu-water-block-round-up-apogee-gt-gtx-vs-storm-vs-fuzion-vs-apogee-vanilla.html
Posted By Date
Watercooling blok - 9lives November 23, 2008
Need some opinions on my water cooled CPU setup - CPUs and Cooling - Forums - www.atomicmpc.com.au September 19, 2008
Thermaltake Bigwater 735 - Page 4 - Forums - OverclockingWiki.org August 14, 2008
EK-Supreme CPU - Acetal block good? - Overclock.net - Overclocking.net August 3, 2008
Watercooling with a CM 690 - Forums - OverclockingWiki.org August 2, 2008
Teraflopy.blogspot.com: Swiftech Apogee GT / GTX - test bloków wodnych + porównanie do Storm-a i Fuzion-a July 24, 2008
Best CPU Waterblock? - techPowerUp! Forums July 22, 2008
tips til vannblokk til GPU og CPU - Forum - Hardware.no July 16, 2008