Hardware Canucks

Hardware Canucks (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/)
-   CPU's and Motherboards (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/cpus-motherboards/)
-   -   Intel Vs. AMD (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/cpus-motherboards/60924-intel-vs-amd.html)

OC-Guru April 29, 2013 07:22 AM

Intel Vs. AMD
 
Yes, this is an Intel vs AMD thread.. but without the 100 page long arguments.

I myself prefer AMD, not because they're better than Intel or worse than Intel, but because I'm just into cheap CPU's :p

Here I will list my personal reasons why I like both Intel and AMD, feel free to contribute to help future members of HWC decide on what they want.

I will start with Intel:
- All-round powerful Processors
- Great when it comes to video editing
- Slightly higher performance in gaming over AMD
- Quite expensive if you want a good one
- Hyperthreading :punk:

And here's AMD:
- Great for multi-tasking (if you have a 6/8 core CPU)
- Cheap and cheerful
- Great CPUs for budget builds
- More than capable for gaming

Here is why we have so many arguments on the forums over AMD / Intel:

OP (posts in AMD CPU Section):
Building new PC, I need a good CPU, can anyone help me?

1st post:
AMD FX-8350 is the best you can get
AMD FX-4100 is a nice quad core CPU

2nd post:
i5 3570k would be nice
or an i7 3770k

3rd post:
Yeah, I agree, 3570k / 3770k ftw

-now.. you see how an AMD thread turns into an intel one? .. then the AMD fan boys come-

4th post:
No, get an FX-8350, dont listen to them idiots above me saying 3570k / 3770k, intel is bad

-then the intel fan boys-

5th post:
dude, you know intel is overall better than AMD, shut up, get a 3570k OP

.. You see?

In this thread I'm hoping to extinguish any hate between AMD and intel.. hopefully we can make a better community and save the arguments!

Feel free the contribute.
Thanks.

great_big_abyss April 29, 2013 07:46 AM

Good Luck extinguishing any arguments here. NOT going to happen.

I used to be a die-hard AMD boy, all the way back to the original Athlon days, and I even still have a 1055T in my son's rig. I also went out and bought and played with an 8350 for a few days.

Then I went out and bought a Z77 platform and a 3570K. And, while it may not have been noticeably faster than the 8350 at anything, when I noticed the drastically lower heat production, I was sold through and through, and wondered what I had been waiting for all this time.

I have both rigs (my son's and mine) in the new computer room in my house. I run mine 24/7 and fold on it. It stays nice and cool I tried running the boy's rig (with the 1055T) and folding on it, but the room just gets waaay to hot. That thing pumps out the heat (OC'd to 3.7). I now keep the boy's computer OFF when he's not on it, and it doesn't fold anymore. Pity, really. That 1055T got some good numbers, it just wasn't worth the heat output.

Oh, and Intel's RST kicks ASS! When I saw how quickly my rig booted into windows for the first time using the Z77 platform, my jaw dropped.


_________________________________________

Anyway, I believe that AMD now has the performance to match Intel, more or less (with the 8350, at least), especially for the price you pay. What they really have to work on now is power consumption (which will bring down heat output). They seem to have the architecture (with Vishera) down pat, now they could use a die shrink.

OC-Guru April 29, 2013 07:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by great_big_abyss (Post 706055)
Good Luck extinguishing any arguments here. NOT going to happen.

I used to be a die-hard AMD boy, all the way back to the original Athlon days, and I even still have a 1055T in my son's rig. I also went out and bought and played with an 8350 for a few days.

Then I went out and bought a Z77 platform and a 3570K. And, while it may not have been noticeably faster than the 8350 at anything, when I noticed the drastically lower heat production, I was sold through and through, and wondered what I had been waiting for all this time.

I have both rigs (my son's and mine) in the new computer room in my house. I run mine 24/7 and fold on it. It stays nice and cool I tried running the boy's rig (with the 1055T) and folding on it, but the room just gets waaay to hot. That thing pumps out the heat (OC'd to 3.7). I now keep the boy's computer OFF when he's not on it, and it doesn't fold anymore. Pity, really. That 1055T got some good numbers, it just wasn't worth the heat output.

Oh, and Intel's RST kicks ASS! When I saw how quickly my rig booted into windows for the first time using the Z77 platform, my jaw dropped.


Thanks for your contribution :)

Yeah, I got my 1100T OC'd to 4.4 with a Antel Kuhler H20 920 .. man, I leave that thing on for 6 hours folding and my room is like 35c haha, its okay if you have a naturally cold room :)

I believe, at the end of day that Intel isn't better than AMD and AMD isn't better than intel, they both do the same thing really.. They both process stuff, they both play games,etc.. just depends on how much time you have on your hands lol

Killswitch April 29, 2013 07:53 AM

I like AMD because of the upgrade paths I was able to take from AM2 all the way up to AM3 without spending huge coin every time I changed hardware. With CPU's being able to work in different sockets I was able to upgrade either my mobo or CPU whenever I found a good deal or could afford it. I never "had" to buy both when I wanted to change something.

OC-Guru April 29, 2013 07:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Killswitch (Post 706058)
I like AMD because of the upgrade paths I was able to take from AM2 all the way up to AM3 without spending huge coin every time I changed hardware. With CPU's being able to work in different sockets I was able to upgrade either my mobo or CPU whenever I found a good deal or could afford it. I never "had" to buy both when I wanted to change something.

ah yeah, the compatibility, something i forgot to list in the OP :)

Thanks for your contribution

great_big_abyss April 29, 2013 07:55 AM

The upgrade path is nice...

When I bought my M5A97 originally, I was running an original Phenom I quad core. Then I put in a Phenom II Quad Core, a Phenom II Hex Core, and finally a Vishera 8350. Add in an 8150, and that's four processor generations, so far.

EDIT: Wait, actually the original Phenom's weren't compatible with AM3 platforms. So, make that three generations.

OC-Guru April 29, 2013 07:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by great_big_abyss (Post 706060)
The upgrade path is nice...

When I bought my M5A97 originally, I was running an original Phenom I quad core. Then I put in a Phenom II Quad Core, a Phenom II Hex Core, and finally a Vishera 8350. Add in an 8150, and that's four processor generations, so far.

Holy cow that's quite the upgrade! :punk:

Thanks again for your contribution

Killswitch April 29, 2013 08:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by great_big_abyss (Post 706060)
The upgrade path is nice...

When I bought my M5A97 originally, I was running an original Phenom I quad core. Then I put in a Phenom II Quad Core, a Phenom II Hex Core, and finally a Vishera 8350. Add in an 8150, and that's four processor generations, so far.

EDIT: Wait, actually the original Phenom's weren't compatible with AM3 platforms. So, make that three generations.

I went from a 5000+ X2 Black Edition, to Phenom 9950 on a Gigabyte AM2+ mobo. That board cooked on me so then I bought an Asus M3A79T Deluxe (also AM2+). After that I upgraded to the new Phenom II 940 when it was released, then to a Phenom II 1100T. Eventually I found a good deal here at HWC on a Crosshair V and ran the 1100T in that for a while. Then the upgrade bug bit again so I went for an 8350 and lived happily ever after. The end. :haha:

One of these days I'd like to try a 3770K and Maximus V with my 7970's just to see if there's any difference other than heat and power consumption.

great_big_abyss April 29, 2013 08:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Killswitch (Post 706066)
I went from a 5000+ X2 Black Edition, to Phenom 9950 on a Gigabyte AM2+ mobo. That board cooked on me so then I bought an Asus M3A79T Deluxe (also AM2+). After that I upgraded to the new Phenom II 940 when it was released, then to a Phenom II 1100T. Eventually I found a good deal here at HWC on a Crosshair V and ran the 1100T in that for a while. Then the upgrade bug bit again so I went for an 8350 and lived happily ever after. The end. :haha:

One of these days I'd like to try a 3770K and Maximus V with my 7970's just to see if there's any difference other than heat and power consumption.

I'm thinking my next upgrade with be to IB-E, and a Rampage V Extreme...I'm just waiting for those chips to come out...

Kilauea April 29, 2013 08:15 AM

I know this is a thread that might be problematic, but for my part I try as much as I can to encourage the small boy; in this case, AMD. In my case, it sort of helps that I am not satisfied by their offerings compared to what I already have, that way it keeps me from wanting to upgrade specially since I am still satisfied by the performance of my Phenom II.

But, I am also realist and I know that if I were to upgrade now, the only worthwhile solution would be to go Intel, maybe in 1 or most likely 2 generations, it will be different (and either way, by then such an upgrade would make a lot more sense).


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 02:02 PM.