Wow, sorry I'm late to the party on this thread.
Hello everyone, I'm new here, and this is my first posting.
I'd like to chime in a little here, if I may.
I've actually gone through this same situation recently, only that I'm upgrading from an old e8400 core 2 duo.
I myself had been debating at the time between going with an 1156/1366 for personal use.
While I may not necessarily be able to max out the cpu load, I'd still like to have ample amount of power available in the event I decided to start using these computers for more than just a few games, and folding.
I also wanted to look into overclocking eventually.
Anyhow... having read that there was new, I ended up buying parts for both 1366, and 1156, as well as an AM3 based 1090T (also bought the just released 1100T to try out... no I do not have a limit for budget, so when I resell the items I don't need/want I'll be giving some folks some really nice deals. Some items I have not even plugged in and used! however since I'm past the point of refunds as I did not start building these until a month later, its a moot point, and I already knew I'd take a loss due to time constraints from my line of work)
For my personal use, I'm leaning towards the 1156, and 1366 units and tinker around with those (yes I know its all old tech now, and about to be replaced), but the way I look at it... the grass will always seem greener in the next pasture.
The current cpu platforms, that are on the market have been tried, and tested.
I also don't see any better time than the present, to be getting the best bang for the buck, with manufacturers and retailers who will want to offload their inventories, to make room for newer items.
Isn't it always like this no matter what consumer products we look at?
I've found myself perfectly happy making due with whats current (ly going out).
I mean especially coming from an old e8400... everything I've tried the past month and a bit is lightning fast!
Whatever you decide to do... hopefully you have as much fun as I have putting together your new system.
For some of us it has certainly been a while, but well worth the wait.
Cheers,
-Gramps