Hardware Canucks

Hardware Canucks (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/)
-   Air Cooling (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/air-cooling/)
-   -   Cooler Master V8 CPU Cooler Review Comment Thread (http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/air-cooling/17590-cooler-master-v8-cpu-cooler-review-comment-thread.html)

AkG May 4, 2009 07:52 PM

Cooler Master V8 CPU Cooler Review Comment Thread
 
Well its that time again! This time we took a long hard look at the CM V8 cooler....and walked away less than impressed. The biggest reason we didn't like this cooler and its lack of fan replacement options and extra mounting points for additional fans....maybe we got a bad cooler, maybe the fan is supposed to be easily replaceable and we got a factory mistake (who knows anything is possible!). Though honestly, unless CM swaps the fan out for a Panaflo or Delta, or any fan with equal an level of cooling power, we don't think ANY single fan will be powerful enough to do this cooler design justice. As it stands, in its stock configuration this cooler falls awfully short of the standard the V10 we reviewed awhile back set.

To read our take on the V8 click here: V8

We hope you enjoy the review...and like the (new) Crucible of Fire & Pain 2.0 we have put together to help really torture new coolers with! Special thanks to Gigabyte and Direct Canada for their amazing support in helping making the new testbed a reality!

Iamcanadian7 May 4, 2009 08:20 PM

Hm, I had a friend use this cooler for a while before upgrading to a Zalman 9900. His temperatures at 3.8 were much better than almost 80 degrees. I believe they were more like 60-70.

Though I don't think he needed 1.45V, that might be the difference. Also for the price, it's not a great value.

I do agree with the whole lack of fan replacement, it's a major PITA to even get at the fan let alone try to replace it.

SKYMTL May 4, 2009 08:24 PM

Voltage has EVERYTHING to do with heat production. Remember, we do multiple mounts in order to reduce the possibility of a wonky mount causing odd performance differences.

Eagle Eye May 4, 2009 11:38 PM

Great review AKG, good too see you're finally working with an updated platform it was always a bit of a shock to see that E4600 still being used.

As for the fan issue if you have a quick moment see if you can't mount a alternative fan (NF-P12) with an elastic. Given it takes away from the asthetics, but there has to be a way to improve performance. Its a $70 dollar investment that sure doesn't perform like one.

EE

aviduser May 4, 2009 11:44 PM

Very well done in my opinon. I know its kind of unorthodox, but I wonder if anyone has (mickey-mouse) mounted fans on either end in a push/pull set up. Would really be interested in results after that.

I think the v8/v10's are more of a "look at my huge bad ass cooler" than bang for buck product.

IRQ Conflict May 5, 2009 09:07 AM

Good Review. Too bad CM had to stoop to this cost cutting fan.

/hugs me Vendetta 2

ImmaPC May 5, 2009 09:52 AM

I thought that the review itself was excellent, great overview and I really like the comparisons between coolers. I still can't believe that this was beaten by the OCZ Vendetta II, I thought it would even beat the V10. Although, I would have liked to have seen the TRUE 120 or the TRUE 1366 (Same thing anyway) in those comparison charts.

Damn, the V8 or the V10 are definitely not worth the money. After reading multiple reviews on both coolers, I'd like to say that you can buy a Vendetta II for $30 or so and it would be a much better buy then any of CM's cooling offerings. The V8 and V10 is a joke. I can't believe that the $175 V10 only beats the Vendetta II by a degree or so, and only at a fairly high OC. Same with the V8, much higher price, much less performance.

Lithotech May 5, 2009 10:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by aviduser (Post 189891)
I think the v8/v10's are more of a "look at my huge bad ass cooler" than bang for buck product.

<----- points to self

I am quite disappointed, because I really wanted one of these. I have to run my Scythe Ninja in pull mode if I want to fill the ram slots with my tall Dominators. I liked the look of the shroud, and in my CM Haf 932 it would definately fit in nicely.

Shroud is glued to the fan? Snuh? OMG, wtf, your kidding me? Meh. :shok:

Glad I didn't already buy one I guess, I have been wanting to for months and managed to resist when I saw it at a small discount. I would have been quite irritated and probably return it.

The shroud is misleading with the allen screws on top, one would think it bolted on top and completely allowed any 120x25mm fan! Arrrrgh, why isn't it so?? :doh:

The crosshatch fins may not help matters, but I am not so sure. The increased turbulance may help the air collect more heat off the fins, and certainly cause more noise. Unless they tested a version with fins orientated the same throughout, and found it to be worse performance... they would never know for sure. Still, you'd think that the more air passing the fins the better.

.

AkG May 5, 2009 10:23 AM

Litotech, you are correct. In a perfect world more air turbulence would/could improve temps (see the OCZ vendetta 2 vs Xigmatek reference desing!) BUT in this case the poor fan is gasping for breath as it has to suck all the air in through those fins and then try and push it out. It is sad, as a small tweak or two would make this one truly kick ass cooler. I can just imagine what V8 2.0 would be like if there was a 38mm fan in the center and 1 on each side! OMG the possibilities!

IRQ Conflict May 5, 2009 12:11 PM

And, OMgoodness, I can't fit my ram modules in anymore. Heh.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 04:45 AM.